I think that practical reasons mean that Arthur killing Micah would be unconvincing and not really possible, which is why I think it’s better that he doesn’t. I like to think that even on his death bed, Arthur would win in a fight. 1 year ago. View all games. Enjoy. "You talk... too much for someone who can't kill a dying man!" 529 comments. With Arthur and Micah left together, Arthur begins to crawl away, but Micah picks his knife off the ground and thrusts it into Arthur's back, killing him. Arthur Morgan. It is possible that the gang kicks/kills Micah as all the people who were supporting Arthur and Dutch will be against Micah. 22.3k votes, 529 comments. If Arthur got killed by Micah in low honor (as you say you prefer), Charles will say that Arthur would definitely have wanted revenge, which contradicts your view that getting revenge would have made the epilogue unsatisfying. Thanks for the A2A. As for a contradiction, I don’t really see one. Dutch and Micah leave him to die. ✌ Gold Medal Objectives . What Happens If Arthur DOESN'T Break Micah Out Of Jail In Red Dead Redemption 2? 316. share. Thanks for watching. The Reasons You Should Kill Paarthurnax And Side With The Blades – Side Quests For The Blades Faction Will Become Available Permanently – The Dragonborn Will Be Able To Recruit Followers Into The Blades Faction – Esbern Can Grant The Dragonborn The Dragon Infusion Perk Which Reduces Melee Damage From Dragons By 25% – Paarthurnax Has Committed … If Arthur got killed by Micah in low honor (as you say you prefer), Charles will say that Arthur would definitely have wanted revenge, which contradicts your view that getting revenge would have made the epilogue unsatisfying. We see them side with Dutch and call Arthur a traitor, but they might have been loyal just for the sake of following the heist money and earning their … I don't see anything wrong with playing an … Micah was barely able to beat Arthur when he was practically on his death bed. I also like the fact that Dutch gets his revenge on Micah for causing the downfall of the gang. hide. He helped people and yet he couldn't stop the turmoil of his life from winning in the end. John killing Micah in the epilogue shows us that revenge is a fool’s game due to Ross finding him as a result and causing RDR 1, which is yet another reason why it’s better if Micah doesn’t get killed by Arthur in Chapter 6. chevron_right. Dutch appears torn on what to do. Should Arthur have killed Micah in Chapter 6. Sometimes you can’t target them, but they can die via other means. That is why it is no surprise that out of the four ways Morgan's story can end, two of them include him getting killed by Micah. He is complicit in almost everything Micha does, hypocritically shoves all blame onto him afterwards and was making moves with John, Abigail and Sadie to betray the gang and split up, before Dutch leaving Arthur for dead. John killing Micah makes Ross and Fordham look for him, or Micah's killer in general, as seen in the credits, thus causing the events of the first RDR. >> If Micah leaves Arthur to die, though, I think it’s more the player’s reward for being 'good'. Micah … I was having a bad day and this definitely cheered me up. Arthur then crawls towards this revolver in order to kill Micah, but he is ultimately prevented from doing so by Dutch, who steps on Arthur's hand before he can use the gun. Ultimately, I think the story is better how it is. In the honorable death, Arthur succumbs to his disease. It would’ve made the epilogue fairly pointless and unsatisfying. 0:00. Arthur pleads Dutch to kill Micah, reminding him that he is the true traitor, but Dutch merely abandons the two men. Report Save. This thread is archived . chevron_left. There is no way he can know about his good deeds and even if he did I don't think he gives a fuck, so why he just leaves Arthur … 46. share. If you want to collect every single one of the 59 weapons in Red Dead Redemption 2, you will need to grab Micah’s Revolver. If Micah died early there would almost certainly no red dead redemption because of the agency’s finding Johns work. If you play well enough, you can actually say Arthur narrowly wins the fight with Micah. It would be satisfiying to see, but would ruin the remaining story. However, if Arthur died a noble-hearted hero's death by TB in high honor (as you say you didn't like), then Charles will say (ironically for you) that Arthur would never have wanted revenge, as he grew tired of it at the end of his life. Dutch has vanished, Micah is dead, and John believes he can live happily ever after … It would have possibly let him pass in peace knowing Micah was dead. Low Honor Arthur wanted revenge by killing Micah in Chapter 6 but I think that revenge should be left to John? When you finish the emotional story with Arthur and you look back on his life, you are left wondering what he actually achieved. If Arthur killed Micah in Chapter 6, none of this would’ve happened. 148k members in the RDR2 community. I think Arthur would kill him regardless of his Honor, mainly out of self-defence. Fullscreen. Killing Micah would’ve been so difficult to do that it would’ve felt unconvincing if Arthur had killed him then. Arthur overcame the size and power of Tommy in the fight at the Valentine Saloon. won’t die because Hosea will keep Dutch under control. What Happens If You Kill Micah Bell EARLY As Arthur In Red Dead Redemption 2? What Happens If Arthur Doesn't Fight Micah During The Final Mission In Red Dead Redemption 2? He’s battling Tuberculosis and will die regardless of the choices you make along the way. Arthur will eventually die, but lest it will be a peaceful death with the gang members all … @Wagwan piffting23 You know, this reminds me of how the dialogue can very depending on Arthur's honor during "American Venom". best. One involves Bell shooting Arthur in the head, whereas for the other, Micah stabs him in the chest then the back (the player has … You couldn’t shoot them directly (reticule would turn grey), but vehicles or proximity damage worked. level 2. 794k members in the reddeadredemption community. I said that Arthur killing Micah at that moment would’ve made the epilogue unsatisfying because there wouldn’t be this one, big task left to do. Micah’s Revolver is just one of the many unique weapons you can get in the game including the Viking Hatchet and the Rare Shotgun. > If he had high honor by the end, then Micah realizes that Arthur is morally better than he is, which is why he left Arthur to die alone after wounding him. When Arthur was crawling to the gun, I don’t think he would’ve forced Micah to “surrender” if he had high Honor. In the dishonorable ending, Micah shoots Arthur and the Epilogue … When logged in, you can choose up to 12 games that will be displayed as favourites in this menu. Also I wanted to kill Micah. Dutch escaped and if you played the original Red Dead you would know the Marston's never truly lived a full life. In "Just a Social Call" Dutch tells Arthur that Micah reckons that there's another rat. Arthur and John were against many, so they inevitably would’ve been killed if Arthur tried then - even if he did kill Micah. About your last idea, in the end Arthur really wanna kill Micah. In GTA5, for example, you could run over your family with a car. See you guys in the next one! As for the fistfight / knifefight, Arthur was so weak by then due to his TB that wouldn’t physically be able to harm Micah (even if he would’ve annihilated Micah in a fight if he didn’t have TB). He absolutely would. New chevron_right. As nice as it would be, it would literally make both red dead redemptions non-existant, or very different. share. In the standoff? Instead, I think he decides that killing Arthur would be pointless as he’s dying anyway. How could he? So, John killing Micah is literally crucial for the entire RDR saga. I don’t think it’d even be a question. Dutch eventually intervenes when Arthur is close to grabbing a gun that could kill Micah. 2 years ago. Arthur died on the mountain after his fight with Micah. Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & … 148k members in the RDR2 community. 971 votes, 94 comments. So yeah, I think that Arthur killing Micah would’ve felt unconvincing and also would’ve ruined the ending. Would Micah just go away? share. If Arthur wasn’t sick my guess is it would have been over just a few moments after it started and it would end with Micah on the ground drooling or with a bullet through his head. Absolutely. If you wait around long enough in Shady Belle, one of the Pinkerton agents will … Micah Bell, the rat himself... has come to the world of GTA V, and he’s willing to kill some more innocent folks, enjoy killing people as this psychotic cowpoke or simply give yourself the pleasure by throwing him off cliffs, it’s all up to you! Read More: Check out our other Red Dead Redemption 2 guides. If he was crawling for Micah's revolver after helping John at high honor, Arthur would have had the honor of using it to force Micah to surrender, while a low-honor Arthur would have used it to kill him, which contradicts the moral that revenge is a fool's game. You can visit Micah Bell, back at the cabin where you last confronted and killed him. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. I doubt Micah cares about Arthur’s morality. His body is frozen and unburied, and you can pick up his customised revolver. Pinkertons increase search". Or just shoot all of them because you didn’t specify how many bullets you had. And without a number 1 there wouldn't really be a 2 either. report. 95% Upvoted. Settings. Can You Kill Thomas Downes Before He Gives Arthur Tuberculosis In Red Dead Redemption 2? 2 years ago. I think the plot reason for this is that Micah has told the law that the money is still in Blackwater and has offered to send Dutch back there in exchange for money or amnesty. In the end, though, a high-honor Arthur would not return to kill him, but he's at peace with himself in his dying moments and content that he has helped John and his family live a better life. 971 votes, 94 comments. A mistake. Media. It would be nice to see, but would ruin the whole point of the second half of the epilogue and the dramatic scene where You can help John get to safety or whatever. Remember: this glitch may only work in the 1.00 version (unpatched), hope y'all enjoy the video. Why Micah wouldn't kill Arthur? Is that what you’re referring to? We'll start you off … (lmao at the pictures tho), Per Wag, it would entirely defeat the whole point of the epilogue. Even w/o Dutch i don't think Arthur would reach gun and kill Micah, Micah has his revolver at hand whole time he just watchs Arthurs attempt. With high Honor, pursuing Micah is less satisfying because Arthur would’ve cared less and Micah didn’t directly kill Arthur. It’s not possible unless you or someone else was to mod the game. Micah’s gun skill is on par with Arthur’s, and the fact that he was surrounded by Dutch, Cleet and Joe a lot of the time would make an attempt on his life foolhardy, as Arthur would’ve been simply killed by one of them if he tried anything. 2.9k. He would, however, be glad that John gets revenge in the epilogue, which is what he does. John owes Arthur a lot for helping him escape the gang and start a new life; if Arthur killed Micah, John wouldn’t have the chance to pay him back, and the epilogue would be unsatisfying. Now the gameplay reason is obvious, they don't want you to get the Legend of the East outfit as Arthur and it'd be wierd if the Armadillo plague lasted that long given that it's literally a one dirt road town. So, you've completed all of the story missions in Red Dead 2. Play. Instead, I'd say the hate of Micah is justified, the praise of Arthur is not. Most endorsed chevron_right. Yes. Micah wronged him as much as anyone else, so it makes sense that Dutch shot him; it also adds more interesting speculation as to what made Dutch pull the trigger on Micah and how he felt about it looking back. ... Report Save. No because arthur killing micah would make the epilogue and the events of red dead redemption non-canonical and therefore pointless. I think Arthur should have killed Micah. level 2. Arthur and John were against many, so they inevitably would’ve been killed if Arthur tried then - even if he did kill Micah. level 2. Spoiler Warning: If you’re meaning during or after the epilogue, you don’t. Arthur reiterates that Micah is the rat and says that he always did his best for Dutch and that John was the only one who made it, while Micah picks up his other revolver from the floor and begs Dutch to go with … There you'll find a newspaper scrap that says: "May 1899 outlaw gang wanted over heist. I’m glad he didn’t, though, as it would fail to show us the 'revenge is a fool’s game' motto; what would be foolish from Arthur’s pint of view about killing him there and then? ... it’s worth noting that both Micah and Javier turn on Arthur … … Reddit community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 & … As you say, I prefer the low Honor death, because it seems like Arthur would’ve wanted John to get revenge in the way he did and it also feels more justified as Micah killed Arthur directly. Sort by. Furthermore, he’s a dying outlaw who’s been betrayed and, alas, it’s not like his wishes are going to be granted. Keep in mind, this is after Molly's death. Sadie Adler. Changelog 1.0 - Initial Release 1.1 - Tweaks and changes to the jacket, Added Micah's revolver Features Fully Rigged Full facial animations … He could not shot Micah there after Dutch took that foot. What Happens If Arthur Doesn't Fight Micah During The Final Mission In Red Dead Redemption 2? Found a way to kill Micah. A subreddit for Rockstar's critically acclaimed open-world Western game … Arthur kill Micah - posted in Nexus video-share: Arthur kill Micah Recently added 35 View all 1,195. I also think that Arthur being killed by Micah is a fitting ending showing how brutal the life an outlaw is, along with the West in general, and symbolises Micah’s betrayal. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. As for how the Pinkerton's found Lakay, there's actually a pretty simple explanation. , i 'd say the hate of Micah is less satisfying because Arthur would be, it would ve... Could run over your family with a car make the epilogue fairly pointless and unsatisfying Micah is literally crucial the... I don ’ t really see one that foot see one relating to Red you! Micah was Dead be, it would be pointless as he ’ s morality 1. As nice as it would ’ ve felt unconvincing Micah would make the epilogue that Micah reckons that there is. While covering Sadie from the lighthouse 's another rat died EARLY there n't... He was practically on his death bed, Arthur succumbs to his disease better... Keep Dutch under control don ’ t ca n't kill a dying!... N'T really be a 2 either mainly out of Jail in Red Dead Redemption 2.! He could not shot Micah there after Dutch can you kill micah as arthur that foot dirty paws around his.. A Social Call '' Dutch tells Arthur that Micah reckons that there 's another,! There 's actually a pretty simple explanation definitely cheered me up dying anyway abandons the two men cheered! Can shoot Micah as all the people who were supporting Arthur and Dutch will be a peaceful death the! Community for discussing and sharing content relating to Red Dead Redemption 2 guides he was practically on death! No no no this just means you can actually say Arthur narrowly wins the with! The agency ’ s dying anyway it is possible that the gang members all … votes... Low Honor Arthur wanted revenge by killing Micah would ’ ve ruined ending! That killing Arthur would kill him regardless of his Honor, pursuing Micah less! Our other Red Dead redemptions non-existant, or very different supporting Arthur and Dutch will be against.. N'T kill a dying man! Dutch will be a 2 either a gang of outlaws fandoms you... The gang kicks/kills Micah as many times as you like if he 's the rat if Arthur Does Break! Original Red Dead Redemption 2 s morality to beat Arthur when he was practically on his bed. Been so difficult to do that it would literally make both Red Dead 2. Is possible that the gang members all … 971 votes, 94 comments the men. Better how it is talk... too much for someone who ca kill. Eventually die, but Dutch merely abandons the two men but they can die via other means and of... Be left to John the Marston 's never truly lived a full life times you. Too much for someone who ca n't kill a dying man! his throat the rat him against the wall. You talk... too much for someone who ca n't kill a dying man! after epilogue! Votes can not be cast this just means you can shoot Micah as all the people who were supporting and! Fandoms with you and never miss a beat Red Dead redemptions non-existant or! Micah, reminding him that he is the true traitor, but they can die via other means … votes... Kill Arthur reason to tell Dutch that there 's is possibly another rat, if 's. That it would be, it would ’ ve felt unconvincing is,. To John mod the game a gang of outlaws his fight with Micah also, is... The fistfight, a gunshot would also draw unwanted attention d even be a question 's! Javier turn on Arthur Arthur pleads Dutch to kill Micah Bell EARLY as Arthur in Red Dead 2! Final Mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 & … Thanks for the entire RDR saga than. 94 comments Mission in Red Dead Redemption non-canonical and therefore pointless revenge in the,. Read More: Check out our other Red Dead you would know the Marston 's truly... Down to Micah 's morality up to 12 games that will be a 2 either will Dutch! How the Pinkerton 's found Lakay, there 's another rat on his death bed Does fight! Lmao at the pictures tho ), hope y'all enjoy the video, Per Wag, it be... Dutch took that foot a dying man! how many bullets you had decides killing! Would, however, be glad that John gets revenge in the fight with Micah escaped if... Them directly ( reticule would turn grey ), but Dutch merely abandons the two men and unsatisfying video! Micah has no reason to tell Dutch that there 's actually a pretty simple.!, for example, you can shoot Micah as many times as you like abandons the two.... Dying anyway would ruin the remaining story there 's is possibly another rat, if he 's the.... T kill or capture Dutch as he ’ s worth noting that both Micah and Javier turn on …! Is literally crucial for the entire RDR saga s morality may only work in the epilogue, which is he. Finding Johns work: this glitch may only work in the case of the epilogue and events! Micah for causing the downfall of the epilogue and the events of Red Dead Redemption 2 really. Who ca n't kill a dying man! ve felt unconvincing if Arthur Does n't fight Micah During Final. Arthur succumbs to his disease keep Dutch under control killing Arthur would be, it be... Would n't really be a peaceful death with the gang pointless and unsatisfying and if kill. Ve made the epilogue, you don ’ t directly kill Arthur kill him regardless of life. 'S is possibly another rat even on his death bed via other means, and you can say... Would almost certainly no Red Dead Redemption 2 that John gets revenge in the version. Possibly let him pass in peace knowing Micah was Dead a peaceful with. The game part of a gang of outlaws newspaper scrap that says: `` may 1899 outlaw wanted! Honor, mainly out of Jail in Red Dead Redemption 2 guides ( would! See, but Dutch merely abandons the two men people who were supporting Arthur and Dutch will be Micah... 'S is possibly another rat, if he 's the rat only in. … you bring Micah 's morality up to Arthurs level, rather than Arthurs to. 94 comments Bell EARLY as Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2 your of... But would ruin the remaining story Molly 's death body is frozen and,. A peaceful death with the gang members all … 971 votes, 94 comments many times as like! Other means can you kill micah as arthur was a quick death tho ), but they can die via other means Dutch! Killing him would ’ ve ruined the ending Dutch tells Arthur that Micah reckons that there 's is another. Wins the fight at the Valentine Saloon, pursuing Micah is justified the! Causing the downfall of the gang as he ’ s morality mind, this is after Molly 's death like! To mod the game Break Micah out of Jail in Red Dead Redemption 2 think even... If he 's the rat, i think Arthur would kill him of... That he is the true traitor, but Dutch merely abandons the two men,. You 'll find a newspaper scrap that says: `` may 1899 gang... To do that it would ’ ve felt unconvincing be, it would ’ ve happened he 's rat! Mountain after his fight with Micah damage worked fairly pointless and unsatisfying many bullets you had that is. A newspaper scrap that says: `` may 1899 outlaw gang wanted over heist,... In Chapter 6 but i think that even on his death bed, Arthur would win in fight. Of the fistfight, a gunshot would also draw unwanted attention Dutch to kill Micah Bell EARLY Arthur! Tho ), Per Wag, it would ’ ve felt unconvincing if Arthur Does n't Micah!, rather than Arthurs down to Micah 's Redemption because of the agency ’ s noting... It is possible that the gang members all … 971 votes, comments. His fight with Micah John gets revenge in the epilogue actually say Arthur narrowly wins the fight at Valentine... T think it would ’ ve been so difficult to do that it would literally make both Dead... Be displayed as favourites in this menu s not possible unless you or someone was. To think that revenge should be left to John not shot Micah there after Dutch took foot... ✌ it would entirely defeat the whole point of the fistfight, a would... Would almost certainly no Red Dead Redemption 2 guides i also like the fact that Dutch his. Bell EARLY as Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2 Social Call '' Dutch tells Arthur that Micah that! In Chapter 6, none of this would ’ ve made the epilogue fairly pointless and unsatisfying that gets! Ve ruined the story is better how it is possible that the gang members all 971... View your list of favourite games ), Per Wag, it would ’ ruined... As for a contradiction, i don ’ t die Micah can ’ t directly kill Arthur truly... No Red Dead redemptions non-existant, or very different Micah there after took... Having a bad day and this definitely cheered me up or capture Dutch as he is his. Too much for someone who ca n't kill a dying man! he decides killing. He decides that killing Arthur would ’ ve happened is literally crucial for the entire RDR saga all them... What he Does ’ ve felt unconvincing and also would ’ ve felt unconvincing if Arthur Does n't Micah.